Sicko thoughts
Last night I got the opportunity to see Sicko for free - apparently as a member of a “who’s who” of local progressive activists and bloggers. I’m not going to post a highly detailed review of Sicko. Other people can and will do that, and I dropped out of grad school for a reason. I just want to post a few of my thoughts on it, with the preface that everyone should go see it.
I’ve always had a love/hate relationship with Michael Moore films. I generally enjoy them and agree with them but feel kind of cheap for only seeing one (very strong) viewpoint. But this movie was mostly an appeal to emotions, and they’re emotions I agree with and can definitely relate to. A while back, Katie posted on her blog about the mounting medical bills we have because we’re having a baby. We have “good” insurance, but we’re paying out our ears in stuff our “good” insurance doesn’t cover. We probably get about five new bills a week. I know we didn’t get both perspectives from watching this movie, but I’m not sure there is or should be another perspective on those mounting bills.
So Sicko was about us. Moore made a point to say that the movie wasn’t about people without insurance. It was about how the “good” insurance that is supposed to help us when we need it is not good at all. The movie was about how insurance companies are neither our friends nor our allies. Indeed, the movie was about how insurance companies do their jobs best when they don’t do their jobs at all. They are the most successful when they collect their premiums and don’t help me.
And they are being successful with us right now. We are doing something as basic as having a baby. For crying out loud, this is basic. Don’t most people have kids these days? Why do we pay so much for insurance that won’t cover this basic, basic thing.
I just don’t get our system. Why do we do this to ourselves? Why? I understand the concept of capitalism and how much it helps us, but if you were sitting in front of a blank screen and had to draw up our medical system, would you do it this way? Would you say “Well, we know we have doctors on one side and people on the other. Why don’t we have this company in the middle to make a profit?” Let me say it again: insurance companies aren’t there to help us. They’re there to help themselves. And we don’t need them!
I know this is going to sound basic, but this is how I see it. All of us are going to need some level of healthcare over our lives. Most people have kids; kids get sick and need shots. Most people get old and get diabetes or other diseases. Most people will get into the occasional wreck and possibly get hurt. Most people will develop allergies or break an arm or get a sinus infection. Most people at some point will need healthcare. So why must we all pay so much for corporations in the middle to make profits off of this need?
As Moore said in the film, why do we pay for some things everyone needs - police, fire departments, the fcc, for crying out loud - but not other things we all need? We all need healthcare. Why can’t it be a right?
Can’t we all admit there are better ways to do it? Can’t we admit there is a better way to live?



